Buying a car within the Rs. 8 Lakh budget has become quite a delight these days. While you can get some pretty loaded hatchbacks, you can also get some decently loaded SUVs in this range. Today, let’s compare the Tata Tiago XZ Plus vs Tata Punch Accomplished! These are amongst the safest cars in their segments and are both equally desirable!
It is pretty clear that both these cars are very different when it comes to the basics. The Punch in positioned as an SUV whereas the Tiago is a hatchback. The Punch offers you a ground clearance of 187mm while the Tiago is good for 168mm. In terms of looks, the Tiago doesn’t necessarily look smaller, but it surely looks shorter. As an overall product, the Tiago is the better looking of these two cars. The Punch is also very good-looking, however, the Tiago feels just a little more well-rounded.
|Tiago XZ Plus||1535mm||3765mm||168mm||1677mm|
Tata Tiago XZ Plus vs Tata Punch Accomplished – Engine
The engine on both these cars is exactly the same, and so are the transmissions. Both these cars are powered by a 1.2L, 3-cylinder petrol engine that makes 84HP and 113nm. The engine is mated to either a 5-speed manual or a 5-speed automatic (AMT). The Punch is 50 – 70 KGs heavier than the Tiago, so performance is ever so slightly better on the smaller one. Moreover, the Tiago is more fun to handle and throw around corners.
Tata Tiago XZ Plus vs Tata Punch Accomplished – Features and comfort
Let’s go with the Punch first. Over the Tiago, it gets 2 major features – keyless go and cruise control. It is also the more comfortable one of the two since it feels a bit roomier on the inside. The ride quality is also slightly better on the Punch because of the higher ground clearance. The Tiago loses out on cruise control and keyless go, but it gets some basic features that this variant of the Punch misses out on. Things like a rear wiper and defogger are missing on this variant of the Punch. The Tiago also gets diamond-cut alloy wheels which the Punch misses out on. On the inside, the Tiago XZ Plus gets automatic climate control and an 8-speaker JBL sound system. The Punch also gets all these features, but the Accomplished variant doesn’t. All in all, in the features comparison of the Tata Tiago XZ Plus vs Tata Punch Accomplished, the Tiago wins.
|Feature||Tiago XZ Plus||Punch Accomplished|
|8 JBL Speakers||Yes||No|
|Rear Wiper and Defogger||Yes||No|
|Automatic Climate Control||Yes||No|
The Tata Punch Accomplished costs Rs. 7.39 Lakhs, and the Tiago XZ Plus costs Rs. 6.82 Lakhs. Both prices are ex-showroom. AMT variants of both these cars cost ~Rs. 60,000 more. Considering value for money, the Tiago looks like a better option in the Tata Tiago XZ Plus vs Tata Punch Accomplished comparison. It brings to the table more features, better looks, and a lower price. So, if you are not hell-bent on buying an SUV, save some money and go for the Tiago!
Here was a detailed comparison of the Tiago XZ Plus vs Punch Accomplished! Other cars you can consider in this segment are the Maruti Celerio, Maruti Swift, Hyundai i10, and Magnite/Kiger. Which one will you choose? Let us know in the comments below!